in Search

USA Cricketer

USACA NW and SW regional elections meandering along

Now, you can get all the USA Cricket updates via Facebook.   Also follow us on Twitter via @dreamcricket

---

[Important Update:  Soon after the publication of this article, USACA announced today that the list of nominees for the regional administrations will be released on March 19, 2011.  The release also noted that ballots must be returned by midnight on April 17, 2011 and results will be published on April 19, 2011.  For the positions of regional representatives, the release also set a timeline of April 30, 2011 for returning the ballots and May 2, 2011 for announcement of the results.]

---

USACA announced in January of 2011 that, following the split of the West into North West and South West regions, elections had been set for the respective regional administrations and regional representatives.

The USACA news release noted that balloting for the South West region was scheduled for February 7, 2011, following which the region was expected to elect its regional representative to the USA Cricket Association’s board on February 19, 2011. In the North West region, balloting was scheduled for February 12, 2011 and the election of the regional representative to the USA Cricket Association’s board was expected to be completed on Friday, February 25, 2011.

According to John Aaron, the Secretary of USACA, all nominations are expected to be finalized some time this week after undergoing the necessary background check. The process for determining eligibility of certain leagues needed additional time, explaining the delay in finalizing the nominations.

As readers are aware, the West region has gained five new members since national elections were last held in 2008 - four of these leagues are in the South West region and one in the North West region. The voting eligibility of the existing and new leagues was to be reviewed by a compliance committee comprising John Aaron, Lisa Brulport and Shelton Glasgow.

According to DreamCricket.com's sources, as part of this process, all leagues were asked to provide certain information such as name of league, names of teams/clubs, contacts for all teams/clubs, league bylaws, schedules, etc. The leagues' responses were audited by members of the committee, and according to Mr. Aaron, each member of the committee had been allocated review responsibilities for certain leagues, and it was based on the findings of the individual committee members that the committee determined the eligibility to vote.

On February 21, 2011, after an e-mailed letter by one of the region's leagues was made public on OnDriveUpdate.com, it became clear that the compliance process had encountered turbulence. In his letter, Faiz Ul Hasan, President of California Cricket League alleged that his league was "disqualified because during the last USACA Elections I did not vote for Mr. John Aaron and his group. I voted for Mr Gladstone Dainty and his group." A response from John Aaron dated February 22, 2011 also appeared alongside the original letter on Ondriveupdate.com. In his response, Mr. Aaron wrote that "three leagues failed to meet some of the compliance attributes within the time frame agreed upon by all of the leagues involved, resulting in them being declared ineligible to participate in the upcoming elections of the two regions. Like any democratic process however, there is always an opportunity to appeal a decision of any individual or committee, and that process has not yet been fully exhausted."

When reached for comment, Mr. Aaron said, “it was unfortunate that the compliance committee’s findings was portrayed by Mr. Ul Hasan as politically biased, since it was the committee’s decision and not mine.” Mr. Aaron dismissed Mr. Ul Hasan’s claim as being indicative of the typical response to such findings, adding that it underscored the need for constitutional reform and a total review of the eligibility of all the leagues of USACA, which are entitled to vote solely on the basis of being full members.

Separately, Mr. Aaron confirmed that he had resigned from his position as the Chairman of the USACA Elections and Compliance Committee. Mr. Aaron declined to comment further regarding the reasons for his resignation stating however that it was not directly related to the rejection of his committee’s findings by USACA’s President Gladstone Dainty. Mr. Aaron reiterated that his committee's recommendations had been submitted to USACA prior to his resignation at a teleconference meeting of the board held last Thursday evening, adding that the three leagues in question were approved to vote in the upcoming elections, without objection from most of the members of the USACA board.

Mr. Aaron said that the USACA board did not review the evidence submitted in support of his committee's recommendations on the ineligibility of the three leagues. He however, refused to be drawn into a controversy on the subject of whether the leagues found to be ineligible had the right to vote in the upcoming elections, reiterating that the compliance committee had performed its duties with integrity and transparency.

With regional and national elections around the corner, the topic of of vote-eligible leagues is now front-and-center. Taking a long-term view, it is of equal, if not greater importance, to review and to make any amendments to the constitution as may be necessary to ensure that it guarantees fair and proportionate representation.

Comments

 

hkgrohan said:

The Western Region was dissolved in November, with elections scheduled for January 21st. That was bad enough. Now it looks like April for elections. And there are so many more holes in the process that this could keep getting pushed out. Whatever is decided, someone will be unhappy, will appeal, and then it will be delayed further.

Wonder if the ICC is watching? Can't look good.

March 15, 2011 11:27 AM
 

Goldenduck74 said:

...and this proves why the next CEO should make Governance and membership issues top of his agenda, rather than trying to make a quick buck by cashing in on the t20 cash-cow.  

Seems to me that bona-fide Clubs need a vote, rather than the leagues.  After all, when it comes to government elections, do individuals have a vote each, or does the household or street have just one vote between them?

March 16, 2011 3:42 AM
 

hkgrohan said:

GoldenDuck - actually, individuals vote for a representative who then votes on their behalf -- that's how government works here. The cronyism in our organization is not just at the USACA level, it's all the way down. If every individual league and then region cleaned up their own acts, there would be an immediate impact on USACA. Excuse the cliche, but we have to be the change that we want in the world.

March 16, 2011 11:08 AM
 

Goldenduck74 said:

I would prefer a system whereby individual clubs vote for their regional representative onto the USACA Board, and then once fully constituted the USACA Board members vote for the individual amongst them to be the Chairman - the current system not only allows for abuse/corruption, but the Board members should be better placed to determine who is best to chair rather than leagues around the nation.  The issue I have is that Leagues are the ones who seem to wield all the power, whereas it should be the Clubs themselves.  I see a league as an organisation that isn't actually producing cricketers, it is merely providing a framework for clubs to play matches against each other (and bringing through cricketers) in an organised fashion but not actually physically playing the game.

How about going one step further - each club gets one vote, but any club who has a properly established youth section, development plan etc gets a second vote?

The fundamental problem seems to be that the USACA has no history of having reliable checks and balances in place to ensure clubs are bona-fide, and the current position is they are chasing the game.

March 16, 2011 1:40 PM

DreamCricket strongly disapproves of spam and we appreciate your taking the time to report this abuse to us so we can remove it accordingly. If you find any content or comments to be inappropriate, abusive or infringing other people's copyright please report it. To report abuse, please email us at content@dreamcricket.com.

This Blog

Syndication

Tags